Where are you from?

For the celebration of Asian Pacific Islander American (APIA) Month, I thought I would share a story that strengthened my identity as an Asian American and helped me understand that being identified as an Asian American is not always easily recognized.

Last week I was at the airport coming home from a college visit. I was sitting at the airport patiently waiting to board. A senior couple behind my friend and I attempted to grab my passport as a joke. After telling me to put away my passport in case of a real theft, we had a light conversation that lasted for about twenty minutes. They were very nice people and I was glad to have someone talk to for the remaining hour.

However our conversation reached a point where I said to myself, “Really?” Whenever I answer this question, it never pleases the interrogator and so he or she would repeatedly ask again until the desired answer was obtained. The question that the senior couple asked was, “Where are you from?”

Instinctively I quickly replied with, “Oh I’m from Boston, MA” seeing as we were at an airport, I was sure they wanted to know which city I was from. They shook their heads and laughed once again asking, “No, where are you from?” This time around I looked at them questionably. “Oh,” I said finally, “I’m from the United States.” No, that did not satisfy the two. But this time they asked, “Where are your parents from?” “China,” I said. Suddenly, I felt a wave of confusion and frustration because they nodded their heads and smiled. Were they trying to understand my ethnicity? But why did they ask such a question in order to obtain it? Did they not think I was American based on how I look? Questions raced through my head as I turned around to face the people again.

Our conversation did not end just yet. Laughingly they asked me yet another question. “Where do you think we’re from?” Before I could even reply, they said, bursting with laughter, “Yeah, we’re going home to Providence, Rhode Island!” I didn’t understand the joke as they continued to laugh, but I felt that they were insinuating something through their grins. I was sure that it wasn’t an intentional, hostile, racist remark, but nevertheless it felt blatant and subtle. How come they were able to say they were from Provide, Rhode Island, and I could not be from Boston, MA?

While I dove deeper into this question I began to think about all the times I was asked, “Do you speak English,” and “Where are you from?” I’ve only been asked twice for each of these questions. Because I live in a very diverse, accepting neighborhood, I was never exposed to such. But now reflecting back, I feel that Asians, among other ethnicities are always labeled as being the “perpetual immigrant.”

When I learned about the term, “perpetual immigrant” from one of the A-VOYCE workshops, I never fully grasped the concept behind it until I experienced it first hand. How I view myself is not how others view me. Are we labeled as perpetual immigrants because there is always an influx of Asian immigrants? Is it because some of us refuse to be identified as American? Or is it possibly because we have not been in the United States long enough to be recognized as Americans? But we have lived on American soil for over 100 years, making a great impact in American history. Then, why? Why are we neglected in history text books? Why is it that there is only a paragraph or less in the World War II chapter that talk about Japanese Internment Camps?

Perhaps it still takes some more time for people to recognize us. However, meanwhile we will simply not be sitting on our chairs, twiddling our thumbs, and waiting for change to occur. No, we will be advocating, bringing awareness, and sharing our stories. Our voices will be heard.

-Tai Tung Village Youth


One thought on “Where are you from?

  1. thank you for sharing your story in honor of APIA month.

    In America, Hispanics and Asians are seen as the perpetual foreigners. We don’t fit in the black and white binary of America. History textbooks have gone extensive ends to marginalize voices of communities of color. It is not that we don’t have long history here, but white America does not want to showcase our history of contributions, struggles and oppression. They want to perserve their pure Anglo-American society.

    Throughout history, American gov’t has barred Asians from citizenship and has blatantly barred our entry to America in general. Throughout history, America has seen Asians as temporary immigrants, brought over to only be laborers. Let the Chinese, Japanese, Koreans and Filipinos break their backs working in the agricultural industry and let the Chinese break their backs paving the way for the transcontinental and turn around and kick, kill and mistreat them. The gov’t systemically reinforces the racial ideology that Asians are not able to assimilate into Anglo-American society and deem us “the other”.

    I think it would be nice for a youth to blog about what is going on in Arizona. What the undocumented immigrants and communities of color are facing there reflect exactly what our Asian American community are struggling with. Their struggles are our struggles. Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere as said by MLK. It is awesome to recognize APIA Heritage Month, but also look at our community in the context of communities of color as a whole 🙂

    Thank you

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s